Menu
Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe
Seafood Restaurant
3.3
Based on 8 reviews
Reviews
El
Elysia M
95 month ago
ABANDONED!
Ma
Mathilde P
96 month ago
Good lunch option and lobster rolls!
Ch
Chelsea
109 month ago
Buy live lobsters, take them home & race them.
Eu
Eugene L
114 month ago
Southern soul style type fried fish. It's not to be missed when you are visiting shelter Island. There is also an outdoor dining area I reccomend during warmer weather.
De
Debbie G
120 month ago
Don't miss their Sunday brunch! Amanda makes an amazing meal from chicken and waffles, salmon, challah French toast and Gouda frittata and shrimp grits! Amazing!!
Ma
Marshall Ryan B
120 month ago
cole slaw ---> food poisoning
An
Angela F
142 month ago
30-45 minute wait is worth it. Smoked tuna appetizer, soft-shell crabs, fried shrimp. BYOB if you'd like a beer. Has a bit of a Nawlins vibe.
Ra
Randy M
149 month ago
Fried chicken is great. Ribs as well. Smoked fish too.
-
Smith Street (Midway Road), Shelter Island, NY 11965, United States, GPS: 41.064518,-72.34116
-
(631) 749-1851
